THOR #612 REVIEW


WRITER: KIERON GILLEN
PENCILS: Doug Braithwaite
INKS: PASQUAL FERRY
COLORED BY: MATTHEW DALE HOLLINGSWORTH
LETTERED BY: NEUROTIC CARTOONIST, INC
COVER BY: Mico Suayan

Size: 32 Pages

Price: $3.99

How you approach a situation like this shows the character of the writer more so then anything. When JMS ran away from the book he helped reinvent because he doesn’t like writing crossover tie-in’s Kieran Gillen was brought in to handle the character. He had a wonderful first arc, trudged through Siege best he could and was then told he was leaving and in his place would be Matt Fraction.

Since then Gillen’s departure has been halted. He had been granted a few extra months on Thor and given time for one last, last minute story arc. Now some writers would have blamed the lack of warning before being asked to stay on and would have pushed Thor and co through a boring post Siege, “ohhh we are so sad we need to grieve” tenure –something I expect Fraction to do as soon as he jumps on the book – but instead he is going out in a blaze of fire. Hellfire to be exact!

As we near the finale of both his short lived, but enjoyable, run on Thor and his final arc – it demonstrates both the writer’s flaws and strengths. There is a lot going on. People are descending from the mortal realm into Hell and Hel. Some crazy cursed women need to eat Asgardian’s souls and Hella has been tricked and Mephisto is being as creepy, yet elusive as ever… the whole thing is very overwhelming. Yet somehow the story is so grand in its scale, leaving behind the melancholy attitude that this sort of post-event would usually bring and instead brings about an engrossing and endearing tale, something that you have to respect Gillen for pulling off right before he hands over the reigns.

Luckily his tale is supported by some wonderful art. Braithwait has outdone himself; you can literally feel the sadness in the eyes of Thor and the other Asgardian’s as they see not only their home, but afterlife too in ruins. The art is both extremely detailed, yet it has a painting like flow – I can’t wait for the team to sink their teeth into images of hell next issue. It is going to be a real spectacle if this is anything to go by.

So what can I say – is this the last grand tale Thor will participate in before Fraction rolls in and makes it like an episode of Jerry Springer crossed with Eastenders? Maybe, for now we will have to make do with a brilliant arc from an underappreciated writer, one who has not only proved himself capable of big books … but one who wholly deserves another shot.

-Josh “Dredd” West

Origami Kid

Twitter.com/origamikid

Comments
3 Responses to “THOR #612 REVIEW”
  1. jdudhead says:

    Great review. Gillen’s run really has been criminally under rated in my opinion as well. His first arc and this latest arc were brilliant Thor stories and took advantage of the rich mythos—dare I say it—even better than JMS did. I do disagree about Fraction’s take on the character however, you should read his previous Thor work, Ages of Thunder. He can definitely write the shit out of some Thor! Anyways, liking the reviews. Keep it up!

    • origamikid says:

      Cheers man, I have really enjoyed the whole run – I thought the bits in between Siege struggled a little bit, but overall he has done a brilliant job with the god of thunder. When a writer that rebirthed the character so well leaves the book it is always going to be tough but Gillen seems to have taken it in his stride.

      Make sure you check out the rest of the reviews and come back this week dude! Reviews will be going up on Friday and Saturday!

      As said I will give Fraction a chance, but his Iron Man is unreadable, clunky and boring, His Uncanny X-Men is all over the place… lack of characterisation on many of the characters, he seems to be very much a “throw in as many X-Men as I can in each issue, regardless of how detrimental it will be to the overall plot”. Didn’t really enjoy his Punisher War Journal that much, it was alright but not great.

Trackbacks
Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] Since then Gillen’s departure has been halted. He had been granted a few extra months on Thor and given time for one last, last minute story arc. Now some writers would have blamed the lack of warning before being asked to stay on and would have pushed Thor and co through a boring post Siege, “ohhh we are so sad we need to grieve” tenure –something I expect Fraction to do as soon as he jumps on the book – but instead he is going out in a blaze of fire. Hellfire to be exact! To Read The Full Review Click HERE. […]



Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 14 other followers

%d bloggers like this: